In a scathing indictment of civic failure, the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court on Thursday came down heavily on the Nagpur Municipal Corporation (NMC) for its inability to maintain basic sanitation in the city, bluntly observing that “Swachh Nagpur, Sundar Nagpur has remained nothing more than a hollow slogan.” The court took serious note of media reports exposing garbage-laden streets and years of neglect hidden behind cosmetic cleanliness claims.
Disturbed by visuals of waste-choked neighbourhoods, the bench ordered registration of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) on Nagpur’s sanitation crisis and indicated that citizens may soon be allowed to file zone-wise complaints through dedicated WhatsApp numbers. Justices Anil Kilor and Raj Wakhode appointed Yashovardhan Sambare to draft the PIL and granted two weeks for its formal submission, signalling growing judicial impatience with civic apathy.
The media report that prompted the court’s intervention painted a grim picture of overflowing garbage bins, stench-filled streets and unattended waste in areas including Mahal, Ramnagar, Trimurti Nagar and Dhantoli. A city-wide assessment spanning Ramdaspeth, Ganeshpeth, Sitabuldi, Subhash Nagar, IT Park Road, Bharat Nagar, Sakkardara, Chitnispura and other localities revealed that the filth was “not accidental, but the result of sustained and systemic neglect,” the court noted, warranting immediate judicial scrutiny.
The failure appears even more glaring in light of the scale of public spending. The NMC spends over ₹8 crore every month—nearly ₹100 crore annually—on garbage collection and transportation through two private contractors. Yet, roads continue to resemble dumping grounds, raising serious questions about accountability, monitoring and value for taxpayers’ money.
While civic officials claim inspections are underway ahead of Swachh Survekshan 2025, citing wall paintings, debris clearance, park maintenance and door-to-door collection, the court observed a stark disconnect between official claims and ground reality. Busy roads and densely populated neighbourhoods remain choked with waste, exposing the gap between paperwork and public suffering.
With Nagpur’s population exceeding 35 lakh and nearly 5.75 lakh households generating waste daily, the city requires at least 550 garbage collection vehicles each day. Fewer than 450 are currently operational, and nearly 10 per cent are reportedly off-road due to breakdowns, leading to erratic doorstep collection and mounting garbage piles.
The administration maintains that 1,300 to 1,400 tonnes of waste are processed daily and that segregation at source is mandatory. It has also assured that the notorious Bhandewadi dumping yard will soon be free of visible waste heaps. However, the High Court remarked that the gulf between official assurances and lived reality is impossible to ignore—it is written across Nagpur’s streets.
Adding to the grim scenario is widespread civic indiscipline. In 2025 alone, citizens paid ₹5.51 crore in fines for violations of basic civic norms. The NMC’s Nuisance Detection Squad booked 45,176 cases, reflecting how disregard for public cleanliness has become routine rather than exceptional.
Official data shows violations across 30 categories, including littering, spitting, use of banned single-use plastic, illegal dumping of construction and demolition waste, improper disposal of biomedical waste and unauthorised public structures. Together, they underline that Nagpur’s sanitation crisis stems from both administrative failure and a collapse in civic responsibility.
With the High Court stepping in, the message is clear: slogans can no longer substitute governance, and neglect—whether by authorities or citizens—will no longer escape scrutiny.
👉 Click here to read the latest Gujarat news on TheLiveAhmedabad.com